Two brands from one state, locked in a rivalry most cue buyers don’t realize is a family argument. Viking has built cues in Wisconsin since 1965; McDermott set up shop down the road in Menomonee Falls in 1975. Both guarantee their cues for life, warpage included. The verdict by tier: a first serious cue is a coin flip settled by whether you need a case. The league step-up goes to McDermott’s G-Series. The collector tier goes to McDermott on program depth, with Viking taking the loyalty vote on service.
That’s the short version. The ladders come first, then the shafts and the joint differences.
BilliardBeast does not retail either brand. Affiliate links go to Amazon and to Billiard & Pool Center, a specialty cue retailer that carries both lines.
The verdict in one table
| Buyer tier | Winner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| First serious cue ($100-$250) | Tie: Valhalla 100 or Lucky L9 | Valhalla for pure cue value; Lucky L9 if you want the included case |
| League step-up ($250-$450) | McDermott G-Series | G-Core shaft standard, deeper model selection at this exact tier |
| Serious player ($450-$800) | McDermott | Defy carbon and i-Shaft options plug into the same butts |
| Collector / custom tier | McDermott for program depth, Viking for loyalty | McDermott’s custom and limited-run program is the deepest in production pool |
| Warranty-first buyer | Tie | Both are lifetime including warpage, the two best warranties in the industry |
Every retailer that stocks both brands answers this question with “you can’t go wrong,” which is true and useless. The tiers above are where each brand actually earns the sale.
The value ladders: Valhalla vs Lucky
Both companies solved the same problem the same way: a budget sub-brand that puts their name in a new player’s hands without diluting the flagship line. Viking calls it Valhalla. McDermott calls it Lucky (and Star, one shelf up).
Valhalla runs roughly $85-$220 across the series. Every Valhalla is a straight, honest maple cue with the fit and finish of something more expensive, and the Valhalla 100 series around $100-$150 is the one we recommend most. Irish linen wrap, hard rock maple, multiple weight options. Our full Viking Valhalla 100 review covers it shot by shot, and it remains the cue our readers buy more than any other.
Lucky runs $62-$175. Same story, McDermott badge: real Wisconsin-built maple cues with simpler cosmetics than the main line. The Lucky L9 at about $150 includes a soft case, which quietly settles the first-cue decision for a lot of buyers, because a decent case costs $30-$50 on its own.
Honest assessment of the tier: at $150 these two cues are interchangeable in play. The Valhalla feels marginally better finished to my hands; the L9’s included case is worth real money. Losing sleep over this choice is the only wrong move.
The league step-up: where McDermott pulls ahead
Between $250 and $450, McDermott’s G-Series is the strongest lineup either company fields, and it’s the tier where this comparison stops being a tie. A G-Series cue brings the G-Core shaft as standard equipment, McDermott’s carbon-cored maple design that stiffens the hit and cuts deflection without going full carbon fiber. The model range at this tier is wide enough to pick by looks and still get identical performance underneath.
Viking’s main line competes here with solid cues from roughly $250 up, built around Viking’s quick-release joint and the same lifetime guarantee. They’re genuinely good. The catalog is just thinner at the exact price points where McDermott stacks options, and the G-Core shaft is a more proven performance story than a standard Viking maple shaft at matching money.
If you’re stepping up from a Valhalla or a Lucky, the McDermott GS02 at Billiard & Pool Center ($195-$340 depending on options) is a representative entry into the G-Series, and specialty retailers carry deeper McDermott inventory than Amazon at this tier.
One ordering detail worth knowing at any tier: weight. Both brands sell their cues in the standard 18-21oz range, and McDermott’s adjustable weight-bolt system lets you change a cue’s weight at home after purchase instead of guessing right the first time. Viking cues are weighted at order. Neither approach should decide the brand, but first-time buyers who don’t yet know their preferred weight get real insurance from the McDermott system; our does cue weight matter guide explains how to pick a starting point.
G-Core vs ViKORE: the shaft technology story
Both brands answer the low-deflection question with engineered maple rather than defaulting to carbon. McDermott’s G-Core buries a carbon fiber core inside the maple shaft. The core stiffens the front end and damps vibration, pulling squirt down below a standard solid-maple shaft while keeping the wood feel that carbon converts miss.
Viking’s ViKORE takes the lamination route: layered maple construction and a performance taper aimed at the same target. It’s a quality shaft that keeps you inside Viking’s joint system and lifetime coverage.
Adoption is the tiebreaker. G-Core has been McDermott’s standard performance shaft for years, with a long track record and wide league presence, and McDermott’s ladder continues upward through the i-Shaft line to the Defy carbon shaft, all fitting the same butts. Viking’s carbon answer is the Siege shaft (about $350). Both ladders work; McDermott’s has more rungs. For the full shaft background, see what shaft material McDermott uses.
Neither brand’s engineered maple matches true carbon deflection numbers, to be clear. If lowest-possible squirt is the mission, that’s a different comparison and a different budget; our best carbon fiber pool cue guide covers that field.
Joints and wraps: the small differences you’ll feel
Joints. Viking’s signature is its quick-release joint, a smooth-faced design that assembles in a couple of turns and produces a solid wood-on-wood feel. McDermott runs a traditional 5/16x14 pin on most models and 3/8x10 on the Intimidator series. Practical consequence: shaft shopping. A McDermott 5/16x14 butt accepts a wide world of aftermarket shafts; Viking’s joint keeps you mostly inside Viking’s ecosystem. Tinkerers should weight this heavily. Players who buy one cue and play it for a decade shouldn’t.
Wraps. Both default to Irish linen at the tiers that matter, with leather and wrapless options climbing the range. No meaningful gap; both companies wrap cues the way Wisconsin shops have for fifty years.
Warranty. The headline for both brands, and a genuine tie. Viking guarantees its cues for life including warpage. McDermott replaces warped shafts for life. In an industry where most warranties exclude warpage entirely, owning either brand means a warped shaft is an inconvenience instead of a loss. That coverage is a real reason to pick either of these brands over imports at the same price; if a shaft ever does move on you, our guide on why pool cues warp covers prevention anyway.
Service: the tiebreaker nobody puts on a spec sheet
Warranty terms tie, so the real question becomes how each factory treats you in year six, and this is where the fan bases split. Viking’s loyalists are loyal specifically about service: repairs, refinishes, and warranty claims handled by the same Wisconsin shop that built the cue, with the kind of turnaround stories that keep people in the brand for three or four cues. It’s a smaller company, and it behaves like one in the good sense.
McDermott’s service operation is bigger and more systematized, which cuts both ways. Warranty execution is reliable and the factory offers repair and refinish work on its own cues, but you’re a ticket number in a queue rather than a name. Neither approach is wrong. Players who plan to own one cue forever tend to weight Viking’s touch; players who climb the upgrade ladder care more about McDermott’s deeper catalog when trade-up time comes.
Buying used: what these brands are worth secondhand
Production cues from both brands hold moderate used value, typically 40-60% of retail for clean examples, with limited runs and custom work doing better. That math produces two practical rules.
First, don’t buy Valhalla or Lucky cues used. New prices are $85-$175 with full warranties attached; saving $40 on a used one while giving up the paper makes no sense.
Second, the used sweet spot is the $250-$450 tier, where a G-Series McDermott or main-line Viking at 50% off is real value. Check the pin matches shafts you might want later, roll the assembled cue on a flat table, and remember the lifetime warranties serve the original purchaser; buying used means the construction is your warranty.
The full spec comparison
| Spec | Viking | McDermott |
|---|---|---|
| Founded / built in | 1965, Wisconsin | 1975, Menomonee Falls, Wisconsin |
| Entry line | Valhalla ($85-$220) | Lucky ($62-$175), Star above it |
| Mid tier | Main-line Viking from ~$250 | G-Series ($195-$340+) |
| Performance shaft | ViKORE laminated maple; Siege carbon (~$350) | G-Core carbon-cored maple; i-Shaft; Defy carbon |
| Joint | Viking quick-release | 5/16x14 most models; 3/8x10 Intimidator |
| Wrap (standard tiers) | Irish linen | Irish linen |
| Warranty | Lifetime, includes warpage | Lifetime, includes warpage |
| Custom / collector program | Custom shop, strong service loyalty | Deepest custom and limited-run program in production pool |
| Aftermarket shaft flexibility | Mostly within Viking’s system | Wide, thanks to common pin sizes |
Common questions about Viking vs McDermott
Are Viking or McDermott cues better quality?
At matching prices, a tie. Both are Wisconsin-built with lifetime warpage-inclusive warranties. McDermott has the wider catalog and deeper custom program; Viking has the quick-release joint and a fierce service reputation.
Are Viking pool cues good?
Yes. Wisconsin-built since 1965, guaranteed for life including warpage, and the Valhalla line is one of the most recommended first cues in pool. See our deeper Viking breakdown for the line-by-line.
Is the McDermott Lucky line worth it?
For a $62-$175 first cue, yes. Real Wisconsin maple with simpler finishes than the G-Series. The L9 with its included case is the pick of the line.
What’s the difference between G-Core and ViKORE?
G-Core is maple with a carbon fiber core inside; ViKORE is laminated maple. Both cut deflection versus standard shafts. G-Core has wider adoption and a taller upgrade ladder above it.
Do both brands have lifetime warranties?
Yes, and both include warpage, which almost nobody else in the industry covers. For a decades-long ownership plan, either warranty delivers.
Related Articles
For more on this topic, check out best brands of pool cues, are Viking pool cues any good, the Viking Valhalla 100 review, the McDermott cues full review, what shaft material does McDermott use, and McDermott vs Predator cues.