8 Ball Scratch Rules: What Happens if the 8 Ball Goes in on the Break?


Pocketing an 8 ball on the break is hard to do, but it does happen from time to time. Sometimes it’s just the random chaos of the break. Other times, when done on purpose, it’s the result of skill combined with a little bit of luck.

But there are different rules floating around concerning this subject. The result of a sunk 8 ball on the break can change depending on the agreed-upon rules of the tournament, pool hall, or your opponent. 

So, what happens if the 8 ball goes in on the break?

There are two different outcomes that are widely accepted by pool players. Bar rules and APA rules state that the shooter wins automatically if he or she sinks the 8 ball on the break. BCA rules are a little different. They give the breaker the option to re-rack the balls or to spot the 8 ball and continue play. Under BCA rules, it does not result in a win. 

Since bar rules tend to vary depending on where you are and who you’re with, I’ll go over BCA and APA rules first. Then we’ll look into bar rules concerning pocketing the 8 ball on the break. 

8 Ball on the Break – BCA Rules

If you’re not familiar, BCA is short for Billiard Congress of America, which is short for Billiard Congress of America Pool League (BCAPL). The BCA was founded back in 1978 and today has more than fifty thousand members and over 500 different leagues from around the world. Its rules are well-known in the world of pool and it’s common for elite-level players to defer to the BCAs rules because they reflect league and tournament play more than the APA rules do.

What BCA Rules Say About Pocketing the 8 Ball on the Break

Under BCA rules, you can’t win by pocketing the 8 ball on the break. Instead, the breaker can either have the balls completely re-racked or they can have the 8-ball spotted and continue the game. 

What Does it Mean to “Spot” the 8 Ball?

To spot the 8 ball after potting it on a break means to remove the 8 ball from the pocket and place it as close to the foot spot on the table as possible without moving any balls. This is usually done as close to the foot rail as possible, as well. This goes for spotting any ball, not just the 8 ball.

What BCA Rules Say About Scratching And Potting the 8 Ball on the Break

What if both the 8 ball and the cue ball go into a pocket on the break? Stranger things have happened. The BCA says that scratching on a break, whether the 8 ball goes in or not, is a foul. In this case, the opposing player has the choice to either spot the 8 ball on the table and continue play with ball in hand, or request that the balls be re-racked and the break done over again. 

The big difference between the two is who gets to make the decision. When the breaker pots the 8 ball, the decision on how to proceed is up to them. If the breaker pots the 8 ball and the cue ball, the decision goes to the opposing player.

How BCA Defines “Ball in Hand” After a Break Scratch

I would be remiss if I didn’t explain to you how BCA defines “ball in hand” after a break scratch because it can be just as confusing as the rules for sinking an 8 ball. Ball in hand for a fall generally means that the opposing player can shoot from anywhere on the table

But, when a player scratches on a break, ball in hand is limited to behind the head string or “in the kitchen” as some players call it. 

Although no precise explanation is given by BCA for this rule, I assume it’s because the balls may still be clustered at the other end of the table, making for too-easy pickings in the event of a scratch on the break. Forcing the opposing player to shoot from behind the head string at balls past the head string may be a way to ensure that the rest of the balls are broken up and the playing field is relatively fair or “level.” 

8 Ball on the Break – APA Rules

APA stands for American Poolplayers Association. It was founded in 1979 as the National Pool League but changed to the APA two years later. It is “the world’s largest amateur pool league,” boasting over 250,000 members. 

The founders of the APA, Terry Bell and Larry Hubbart, developed a handicap system called The Equalizer® that allows all pool players of all skill levels to join leagues and enter tournaments. In 2010, Guinness World Records deemed the APA’s World Pool Championship in Las Vegas the World’s Largest Pool Tournament.

As you can imagine, there are plenty of billiards players who defer to the APA’s rules when they cue up at a table. Luckily, the APA’s rules for potting the 8 ball on a break are pretty clear. 

What APA Rules Say About Pocketing the 8 Ball on the Break 

When playing under APA rules, pocketing the 8 ball on the break results in an automatic win. This is pretty clear cut and easy to follow. Although it’s possible to practice pocketing the 8 ball on the break, there are so many other factors determining whether you’ll actually sink the ball. This may be the reason behind this rule. If you’re good enough to sink the 8 ball with skill and a bit of luck, you deserve a win. 

But, if you scratch on the break, it’s a different story. 

What APA Rules Say About Scratching And Potting the 8 Ball on the Break

If you scratch and pocket the 8 ball on a break, it’s considered an immediate loss. This is likely a continuation of the APA rules for scratching on an 8 ball shot, which always results in a loss. However, if you scratch on a break and the 8 ball does not go into a pocket, it’s considered a foul. In that instance, the opposing player has ball in hand behind the head string.  

8 Ball on the Break – Bar Rules

Bar rules are a little harder to pin down. Sometimes called “house rules,” these can vary depending on the establishment or even the person you’re playing with. If you’re playing at someone’s house, it’s generally their house rules that you will follow. It’s always good to get clear on the rules before you start a game in order to avoid confusion or costly penalties. 

Some bars or pool halls will have standard 8 ball rules state clearly while others will not. If there are no rules set forth by the establishment, it’s up to you and the opposing player to agree on a set of rules to follow during the course of the game. However, bar rules generally follow similar guidelines as APA rules. 

What Bar Rules Say About Pocketing the 8 Ball on the Break

Most bar or house rules state that pocketing the 8 ball on the break results in an automatic win. In this case, the opposing player can ask for a re-rack to start the next game or simply request that the 8 ball be spotted so play can continue without re-racking. In either case, the breaker has won that game.

What Bar Rules Say About Scratching and Potting the 8 Ball on the Break

Like APA rules, bar rules typically state that sinking the 8 ball and scratching on the break results in a loss. Without this rule, players would have no reason not to try to pot the 8 ball on the break every time, which can sometimes make for a less-than-ideal break for the opposing player. 

However, some bar rules state that scratching at all on the break results in a loss, so it’s best to get clear on these rules before you try an 8 ball shot on the break.

What to Know About a Legal Break

Not performing a legal break is a foul under BCA rules. And, under all rules, performing a legal break limits your options as to how you can shoot. It’s good to know what a legal break is anyway, but it’s also imperative if you plan on trying to pocket the 8 ball on the break. 

BCA Rules – Legal Break

Under BCA rules, a legal break must be shot from behind the head string. One of two things must happen for the break to be considered legal. The break must either result in one or more pocketed object balls or it must drive a minimum of 4 object balls to impact the rails. If the shot is not legal, the opposing player can:

  • Play the table as is.
  • Request that the balls be re-racked and break him or herself.
  • Request that the balls be re-racked and require the offending player to re-break. 

APA Rules – Legal Break

APA rules are a little different when it comes to legal breaks. The breaker must shoot the cue ball from behind the head string and impact either the head ball or second object ball on the rack. The cue ball must not impact a railing before contacting an object ball. Like BCA rules, at least one ball must be pocketed, or at least 4 of the object balls must impact the rails. 

  • If the break is not considered legal, the player who broke must re-rack and re-break. 

If the break is not legal and it results in a scratch, the opposing player must re-rack and re-break. 

Bar rules vary in regards to legal breaks, but they are most often the same as the APA rules outlined above

How to Rack Balls Properly for 8 Ball Pool

Although most players know the basics of racking properly, it can be a point of contention among casual players. Some people insist that the balls should alternate solids and stripes throughout the rack. Others insist that it doesn’t matter as long as the 8 ball is in the middle. Here’s what the rules state. 

BCA Racking Rules

A proper rack under BCA rules is fairly straightforward. There are four criteria to meet. 

  • The head ball must be on the foot spot. 
  • The 8 ball must be in the middle of the rack (third row, middle ball).
  • There must be a solid object ball in one bottom corner of the triangle.
  • There must be a striped ball in the other bottom corner of the triangle. 

APA Racking Rules

APA rules are a little more detailed in some ways but less so in others. 

  • The head ball must be on the foot spot. 
  • The balls must be touching, or “frozen,” as close as possible.
  • The 8 ball must be in the middle (third row, middle ball). 
  • The breaking player can request a re-rack if he or she so chooses.

Bar Racking Rules

Again, these rules vary and are often some combination of BCA and APA rules. However, the head ball must always be on the foot spot and the 8 ball must always be in the middle. The other details you should determine with the opposing player. 

Conclusion

Now you should be equipped with enough information to know exactly what happens if you sink an 8 ball on a break. However, since there are different sets of rules, it’s best to be absolutely clear on this before you start the game. If you and the opposing player have different rules in mind, the game is likely to be stressful and frustrating instead of fun and relaxing like pool should be!

Other Articles You May Be Interested In

Recent Posts